OM Property Management Ltd v Burr: Liability has to crystallise before it becomes a cost

Regular readers of my blog will recall that I wrote an article last year on the Upper Tribunal case of OM Property Management Ltd v Burr which gave guidance upon what is known as the 18 month service charge rule under section 20B of the Landlord and Tenant 1985. Landlords are prevented from recovering service charge costs from tenants if they were incurred more than 18 months before they are demanded unless the correct form of prior notification is given.

The facts were peculiar in that they concerned the cost of heating a communal swimming pool, a facility that no doubt more long leaseholders would want as standard in their blocks.

OM Property Management Ltd (OMP) was given incorrect information about the gas supplier for the swimming pool heating system which eventually led to a bill for the period 2000 – 2007 in the sum of around £135,000. In the Leasehold Valuation Tribunal the LVT panel determined that the gas supply expense was incurred when the gas was supplied and not when the invoice was levied by the supplier.

OMP appealed to the Upper Tribunal who reversed the LVT’s decision on the basis that cost and liability are conceptually different, although there could be issues in cases where invoiced costs were diluted and not paid until outside the relevant period. In this case it was determined that the service charge cost was only incurred at the earliest, when the gas supplier rendered its invoice. That, you may have thought was the end of it. However, Mr Burr appealed to the Court of Appeal.

The Court of Appeal held firm and agreed with the Upper Tribunals view that a cost must crystallise for the 18 month clock to start ticking. The cost in this case only crystallised when there was a demand for payment by the supplier.

Mr Burr had argued that the purpose of section 20B was defeated by this approach in that it effectively removed the tenants statutory protection as there would be no end date for the payment of charges if invoices could be delayed for many years and tenants could not prepare for this (I don’t know if the impact of section 20 consultation was raised in the context of this proposition). However, the Court of Appeal disagreed with this and effectively said that the purpose of the statutory protection was not as wide as Mr Burr submitted.

About leaseholdlawyer

This entry was posted in Leasehold Opinion, News and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to OM Property Management Ltd v Burr: Liability has to crystallise before it becomes a cost

  1. Lauren Wadey says:

    Chris – I have a 2008 yr end accounting invoice, issued in 2011, paid by S/C in 2011/12! (not by us I hasten to add) The same agent managed the block for the duration (2007-2012). Therefore by this ruling, and without a notification in 2008/9, this is a potential breach of Sec 20B- correct? I presume this in light of the fact that the Agent knew professional to expect this invoice?

    • Hi Lauren,

      Sounds like a possible conflict of interest for the agent invovled and the historic expenditure may have become irrecoverable. The leaseholder could still seek a retrospective determination in relation to those sums but the commerciality of such a claim may be questionable.

      • Lauren says:

        Conflict- how so? If they did the accounts you mean?
        Yes commercial to challenge is not viable. Very frustrating when that’s the case.

      • Their interests as managing agents of the block conflict with their clients interest as leaseholder. It may still be worth a complaint to one of their professional bodies.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s